Addressing Study Error in the National Evaluation of Upward Bound – Do the Conclusions Change?

This report examines the Upward Bound National Evaluation random assignment study that followed a multi-grade cohort from 1992-93 to 2003-04, based on four basic assumptions of random assignment studies.

Pell Institute report

Moving Beyond Access – College Success for Low-Income, First-Generation Students

A number of sampling design and non-sampling error issues combined together to confound some of the major conclusions that have thus far been published concerning Upward Bound (UB). This report examines the Upward Bound National Evaluation random assignment study that followed a multi-grade cohort from 1992-93 to 2003-04, based on four basic assumptions of random assignment studies:

  • The sample is representative of the population for which the study is intended to generalize;
  • The treatment and control group are equivalent on factors related to outcomes;
  • The treatment and control group are treated equally except for the treatment; and
  • The treatment and control group are mutually exclusive with regard to the treatment.

Our major finding is that when study error issues are addressed, the Upward Bound program demonstrated statistically significant and substantive positive impacts on the major goals of the program, post-secondary entrance, application for financial aid; and attainment of post-secondary credentials.

GET THE REPORT

More Research

The Pell Institute shares the mission of the Council to advance and defend the ideal of equal opportunity in postsecondary education.

Featured News

Support Us

If you are a student support services professional, thank you. You are an unsung hero for all the good that you do, and surely you know by now that COE has your back.

Donate

Partner

Through strategic collaborations, we work to strengthen quality, opportunity and access to education for all American students — the next generation of global leaders.

partner with us

Join Us

Join more than 1,000 colleges and community agencies committed to postsecondary opportunity for low-income, first-generation students, students with disabilities in all 50 states, Washington, D.C., the Pacific Islands, and Puerto Rico!

become a member